As academic writing becomes increasingly standardised what counts as an interesting paper?
Academic writing is often criticised for its tendency to be arid and unengaging, but what makes a paper interesting? Whilst there is always an intangible element to the quality of being interesting, Manuel Goyanes draws on a study of journal editors in the field of communication studies to outline five dimensions that contribute to a paper being interesting and hence influential.
As social scientists, we want to produce interesting and influential studies. The dominant view in academia is that research is a quest for truth and thus, a research paper becomes influential if it is regarded as true. However, like other occupations, research is a matter of craft. A professional architect, musician, or painter, can easily design a chalet, compose a toccata, or paint an impressionist canvas, by following the principles, norms and values of their respective fields. However, from the generation of standard commodities, by obeying the rules, to the design of fascinating works, by transgressing them, lies a great leap.
Like art, interesting research may seem nebulous, frugal and volatile, but there are certainly some dimensions that are able to capture it.
Likewise, in my own field, doing communication research is up to a point not hard. Following the research orthodoxy, a communication scholar could effectively create legitimate science. Indeed, hundreds of research studies are published every year that feature legitimate science, but how many of them are interesting? Interesting research is not only a representation of scientific truth, but is also a call to the appreciation of human creativity, its vocation of rupture and its ability to stimulate and challenge. Like art, interesting research may seem nebulous, frugal and volatile, but there are certainly some dimensions that are able to capture it. So, what is interesting in communication research? In a recent study, I posed this question to the editorial boards of top-tier communication journals, opening up a discussion germane to the need (or not) to challenge the over-standardisation of research productions. Here, I outline five different dimensions that emerged from these discussions.
Counterintuitive
Above all, studies that challenge the assumptions of their audience are regarded as interesting and thus more likely to be read, understood, and remembered. Challenging the ontological, epistemological, and methodological assumptions that underlie specific literature can be characterised as challenging paradigmatic assumptions. Given their revolutionary nature, ground-breaking studies are, however, very rare in sciences and are for most scholars beyond reach. As the philosopher of science Thomas Kuhn suggested, the bulk of scientific work is done by normal scientists tied to specific research paradigms. However, healthy knowledge production requires a balance between the development, refinement and exploitation of existing knowledge and methods and the exploration of possible new directions. A central question, therefore, is how a good trade-off between cumulative competence and a capacity to think differently can be accomplished. Short of initiating a wholesale paradigm shift within the discipline, there are ways in which research can be counterintuitive. For instance, counterintuitive articles, critically problematise a particular theoretical framework, a vocabulary and/or the construction of an empirical terrain. They also show creativity and personality in style and structure and communicate an original, interesting idea offering support for it.
Foundational articles
Foundational articles are studies that establish the tenets of future large-scale research areas and, as a consequence, their impact on the field can only be measured over time. Pioneering articles are often the products of a field’s great masters and as such represent the starting point of an academic trajectory, for which they serve as a reference point for revision, improvement and further contributions. Foundational research articles also provide the tenets of an original theory that will become systemic. Their practical and theoretical relevance makes them a crucial resource for many research projects and essential reading for research and learning the foundations of theory.
The new approach
The new approach consists of two strategies: (1) the application of an established theory in new-found (usually) digital conditions and (2) the application of a traditional theory/perspective from other fields to understand and explain related phenomena. Both strategies present important commonalities. First, instead of a strong and narrow focus on some issues within a well-defined, specialised intellectual terrain, the broad spectrum of new approach articles open up research opportunities through cross-fertilisation of theoretical frameworks, enriching the field and scholars’ research competence. In the first strategy, researchers are driven forward by an exploratory logic dominated by the questions
Quality and exemplarity
Quality and exemplarity papers describe what has broadly, but in particular in the context of publishing in leading communication journals, come to be regarded as ‘sound research’: papers solidly grounded in theory and well executed methodologically. They represent excellence in theory building/testing and orthodoxy in scientific practice and methodological rigour. Quality and exemplarity research articles fundamentally test, extend, or build new communication theory. Therefore, research articles must make strong empirical and theoretical contributions and should highlight the relevance of those contributions for current discussions in the field. In order to accomplish the intended ‘theoretical contribution’, quality and exemplarity articles usually follow three strategies: (1) to test intuitive or traditional theory not supported by empirical research, (2) to build new theory based on the exploration of the mediators/moderators and the antecedents/consequences that explain the relationship of core constructs in a validated theory, and (3) to combine both previous strategies.
Insightful and Practical
Finally, Insightful and Practical are those empirical studies that provide rich examples and vivid (thick) descriptions. For this dimension, much credit is given to writing itself, and thus to narrative mastery and rhetorical aesthetics. This last category proves that writing with personality and empiricism is a possible combination. This scholarship comprises mostly of qualitative studies, based on interviews, focus groups and/or observations to gather empirical evidence, relying on critical perspectives to frame the study and interpret this evidence. In insightful and practical studies, authors are also supposed to point out the normative and practical implications of the findings and thereby to address potential actions, visions or considerations that improve the situation of particular communities and provide relevant information to facilitate the implementation of practitioners.
The purpose of this research was to explore what constitutes interesting research. This was motivated by a widespread concern that mainstream research is invariably the product of standardised research practices promoted by scientific journals. My intention is that the dimensions outlined above provide useful insights and a framework for authors, reviewers and editors to better assess their scholarly contributions. As an antidote to dull research (readers can use their judgement and experience to delimit its extension). Whereas advice to academic authors often focuses on the need for specialisation and incremental advance, I have sought to shed light on a wider range of criteria that underscores research that is truly interesting.
This post draws on the author’
Note: This article gives the views of the author, and not the position of the LSE Impact Blog, nor of the London School of Economics. Please review our comments policy if you have any concerns on posting a comment below. Manuel Goyanes, PhD, teaches at Carlos III University in Madrid and his main interests are in media management and sociology of communication sciences. He is the author of Desafío a la Investigación Estándar en Comunicación. Crítica y Alternativas, Editorial UOC. His work has appeared in journals such as Information, Communication and
This post draws on the author’
Note: We produce non-plagiarized original content for high impact journals and periodicals.
Author’s satisfaction is the prime objective of Wriedi.com which depends upon the requisite quality of the content and affordable cost. Author/Researcher can avail this service of following options/guidelines: It incorporates the writing of manuscript a research paper/case study/case reports from Author’s Results/Data/Graphs/Tables/ Self-Written/Self-Raw Material or through secondary data where author submit the document* with following materials: It includes the writing of manuscript a review paper only by the subject expert from afresh-scratch writing where author submits the general idea or outline of the proposed work or any required publishing guidelines and instructions which includes following main aspects: Note: We produce non-plagiarized original content for high impact journals and periodicals. Critical Review, Literature Review, Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis, Mixed Studies Review, Mapping Review, Overview, Qualitative Systematic Review, Qualitative Evidence Synthesis, Quantitative Systematic Review, Quantitative Meta-Analysis, Qualitative Meta-Analysis, Rapid Review, Scoping Review, State-Of-The-Art Review, Systematized Review, Umbrella Review, Systematic Search and Review etc. Our epidemiologists, biostatisticians, and clinical data analyst experts are promptly ready for the data analysis and interpretation according to the client requirements. Our dedicated data analysts will review the data sets and any guidelines if provided by the client. Further, the data sets are assigned to our expert Bio-Statistician or Epidemiologist where an expert will summarize the data thus will conduct and analyze the data using SAS, R, MATLAB, SPSS, SPSS Meta-Analysis, STATA, 6sense, Oracle Crystal Ball, or through any specific software where the project has special requirements. For more information please write to " This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. " 1. Journal Selection: Our experts will select the best match of the Scopus/Web of Science/Pubmed etc indexed journal for your manuscript. The expert will ensure the most impact &
2. Journal Submission: Our experts are experienced professors/assoc. prof./asst. prof. who have already published their papers in high impact journals. They understand the technical requirements for submission. Experts will format your manuscript and figures to comply with the guidelines of your target journal, and finally complete submission to the journal on your behalf. The expert will draft a cover letter addressed to the journal editor. 3. Reviewers Comments: If your manuscript receives reviewer comments from the journal, we shall communicate this to its author for incorporating these changes and our experts will only edit and format this for the same. 4. Resubmission Support: However, if your paper gets rejected, we shall help you submit your paper to another journal and the same process followed. 1. Manuscript Writing Service Fee: Price starts from US .75 to $1.50 per word Note: The final estimated cost will be available on author’s request at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. How to Pay: PayPal: Authors/Researchers can pay the requisite fee through PayPal. WriEdi will send the PayPal invoice having writing details and charges at the author’s email address to pay the manuscript writing fee. Manuscript Writing Timeline: 25 Days to 50 days 2. Publication Support Service Fee: US $1500* per article Writers Academic Level: MD, PhD, Post Doc having above 10 years of academic experience in respective fields. *Half Payment (Fee) Method (Optional): The author can opt to do the first half payment of total before the start of the work and the second half during the first review or revision by the author. Payment can be done through PayPal. WriEdi always sends the detailed fee invoice towards payment. Free Features (Author can share particular institutional/ journal guidelines with writers if applicable): The author will get n number of revisions and corrections from the respective expert subject writer. Writing progress will be shared with the author in 5 days interval. Writing + Editing + Plagiarism Checking + Proof Reading + Professional Writing + Written document Review from Our Editorial Board Members 2. Authors can send the requirements at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. Please send your queries relating to Manuscript Writing Services for Journals at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. *Writing Service Process Fee will be accepted after approval from experts about the possibility of writing the document. My nursing paper online nursing writing services. Paper writing experts is a reputable college paper writing service that has earned the trust of thousands of students worldwide because we pay utmost attention to deliver high quality custom paper to every our every client. Writing is exciting
In addition, they master all formatting styles and know the structure of any assignment. Pte writing questions write essay. Cheap essay writing service with best writers write my essay. If you're new to freelance writing, you'll soon discover that all job posters at job marketplaces (. Ask academic writers for a free abstract to gauge the writers' skills before paying, just to be sure they can write your paper. Ghost writer for students academic paper essay help services tutors will notice that academic paper writing companies plan writers and consultants you are able to. Academic writing in the social sciences, including writing in academic business studies, often has combined characteristics. If you are admirer for books, freebookspot can be just the right solution to your needs. They have experience with the difficulties academic paper writing companies that come with researching, coming up with a good outline, and writing an essay. As anyone who's ever put off a term paper will tell you, good research takes time. Assignment help online - we can do your homework 24/7. Writing an academic paper for publication : essay. Academic writing needs to be in a formal styl e - not written as we speak. (exception: sometimes after a long hiatus it's useful to remind the reader of. Samples of mba essays by real candidates who were accepted to wharton, harvard, insead and other top ranked business schools. Critical essay ophelia with writing the introduction of an academic essay top managers must seek the angular velocity to be the difference between them to be.About the author
Manuel Goyanes
Academic paper writing
Writing Service Methodology
1. Primary Writing Service (Based on the Author's Research and Provided Data):
2. Secondary Writing Service (Review Paper Only):
Types of Reviews Cover:
3. Data Analysis Services:
Publication Support Services:
Cost: Writing Service Charges* (2020-2021)
How to Start:
Academic paper purchase